Trust A Liar? by Art Smukler, MD, author & psychiatrist

Decades ago as a young psychiatrist, my patient Jeremy, a 16 year-old boy who I hospitalized on an adolescent unit because of rampant drug use, running away from home, and stealing, was doing well. He participated in group, individual, and family therapy, did his school work, followed the adolescent unit rules, and told me how he was “a changed person”.

His mom warned me numerous times that whatever came out of Jeremy’s mouth was a lie. Nevertheless, after 4 weeks of excellent behavior, I made plans to discharge Jeremy and see him as an outpatient.

That night I got a call at 4 AM. Jeremy was in full restraints because he had tried to burn down the hospital and then violently attacked staff members.

To sum up a frustratingly long story, after many months of intensive inpatient therapy I again believed that Jeremy was improving and transferred him from the closed unit to the open unit. The next day, a few hours after a therapy session with Jeremy in which I silently congratulated myself on how well my approach was going, I got an emergency call from the hospital. Jeremy had run away.

Months later he was caught robbing a convenience store and placed in Juvenile Detention.

Years later I ran into his mother. She reported that he never returned home and was currently in prison for assault and breaking and entering. She said that from the beginning she hoped that I could help Jeremy but deep down knew that it was hopeless. He was a liar from the time he was a little boy and that never changed.

So, my honest and focus-on-the-positive readers, what is the moral of this true Tale From Smukler’s Couch?

Don’t trust liars.

Whether they are spouses, politicians, investment counselors, or “friends”, liars lie. One important characteristic of sociopaths (people with no conscience) is that many of them are really likable. They are great con men and their lies are very, very believable.

Most of us want to see the best in our fellow humans, but that doesn’t work with liars.

Does this remind you of anyone I’ve been railing against?

Happy reading.

Art

#conmen, #liars, #sociopaths, #sociopathicpoliticians, #treatingsociopaths

WHO’S REALLY CRAZY? by Art Smukler, MD, author & psychiatrist

In 1963 President John F. Kennedy signed the Community Mental Health Act into law. $365,000,000 was authorized to start community based mental health treatment programs, so that the mentally ill could be treated at home rather than in horrifying, ancient hospitals where they were often just housed. The act was lauded as the beginning of a new era for treating mental illness.

Now 50 years later, the results are utter chaos and inhumanity. Many of the mentally ill now sleep under freeways, roam the streets, urinate and defecate wherever, and attack random people because they feel that they are being threatened. 

Why did this wonderful idea fail?

Politics! The politicians refused to allocate enough money to fund community mental health centers and build new state-of-the-art acute-care hospitals. 

It really is that simple. Psychotic people need laws to get them admitted, against their will, to a hospital. Plus, their psychological treatment needs to be funded. 

Closing the antiquated psych hospitals was a great idea, but then all the saved money went to everything but mental health. 

Did the politicians really believe that psychiatric illness would just disappear? Poof!

They’re crazier than the poor psychotics roaming the streets. 

Oh. And did I mention that the politicians cared more about getting re-elected than doing the right thing? Silly me. Finally, after 50 years of chaos, maybe things might change.

Please check out THE REAL STORY and NINE NORTH. Thanks.